The Muslim Brotherhood Memorandum: Valid Concern or Islamophobia?
By Jim Davis
Embers of Truth
Opinion / Commentary

There are some subjects we are apparently not supposed to talk about anymore. Ask the wrong question and somebody will tell you that you're spreading fear. Question an organization or ideology and someone will accuse you of attacking an entire group of people. And sometimes those accusations are justified. But sometimes they become a convenient way of avoiding a question that deserves an answer. The Muslim Brotherhood's 1991 memorandum concerning North America is one of those questions. I approached this the same way I've tried to approach every Embers of Truth investigation: forget the talking points for a minute and go back to the evidence.
What does the document actually say?
Who wrote it?
How authoritative was it?
And most importantly, when we look at what happened afterward, can we prove that any parts of the strategy were actually put into practice? Those are legitimate questions. That doesn't make somebody anti-Muslim. It makes somebody curious. And what I found deserves a serious conversation.
First, the Document Is Real
Let's get that out of the way. We're not talking about something somebody posted on Facebook or a document invented by a political activist. The document is titled An Explanatory Memorandum on the General Strategic Goal for the Group in North America. It is dated May 22, 1991, and attributed to Mohamed Akram, who was identified as a member of the Muslim Brotherhood Shura Council in North America. Most importantly, it later entered the federal court record as Government Exhibit 003-0085 in the Holy Land Foundation case.
So whether somebody likes what the document says or hates what it says, its existence isn't really the question. The hard part is deciding what it means.
And This Is Where We Have to Be Careful
I've seen people describe this document as if every word in it was formally adopted as the Muslim Brotherhood's unquestioned master plan for America. I don't think the evidence lets us say that quite so confidently. The memorandum refers to an earlier long-term plan that it says had been approved and adopted in 1987. But the 1991 document itself appears to have been submitted as an explanatory supplement for leadership review and discussion. That isn't a meaningless distinction. I haven't seen the council minutes or a recorded vote proving that every recommendation in this 1991 memorandum was formally adopted.
Does that mean we should ignore it?
Absolutely not.
This wasn't some random person writing down a fantasy. It came from inside the leadership structure and was addressed to the Brotherhood's North American leadership. That's important evidence. But if we are going to demand honesty from everybody else, we have to demand it from ourselves. So here's what I'm comfortable saying: This was serious strategic thinking from inside the North American Muslim Brotherhood leadership structure. Beyond that, let's follow the evidence.
The Words Should Concern You
Some of the language is impossible to brush aside. The memorandum discusses establishing an effective and stable Islamic movement led by the Muslim Brotherhood. It talks about expanding the observant Muslim base. It talks about unifying and directing Muslim efforts. It talks about presenting Islam as a “civilization alternative.” And then there is the language that has gotten the most attention. The document describes Brotherhood work in America as a “Civilization-Jihadist Process” and speaks about “eliminating and destroying the Western civilization from within.”
Read that again.
I don't care whether the organization involved is Muslim, Christian, atheist, communist, socialist, fascist, or anything else. When an internal strategic document talks about destroying our civilization from within, I think Americans have every right to ask questions. That isn't Islamophobia.
That's common sense.
But Here Is Where Things Get Complicated
The memorandum wasn't primarily laying out a battlefield strategy. It was talking about institutions. Build organizations. Build Islamic centers. Develop leaders. Create networks. Form coalitions. Establish a lasting presence. Think long term. So I asked the obvious question:
Did those things happen?
In many cases, yes. Muslim student organizations developed. Islamic centers and schools expanded. National religious organizations were created. Property institutions, charities, publishing operations, political organizations, civil-rights groups, and advocacy organizations grew. Some of those institutions have historical connections to individuals associated with the Brotherhood. That deserves examination. But this is also where we can get ourselves into trouble if we aren't careful. Because similarity is not proof.
A Mosque Is Not Evidence of a Conspiracy
Think about it. My Christian faith is important to me. Churches don't just hold worship services. They operate schools. They have youth programs. They feed people. They organize charities. They engage politically. They work with other churches. They develop future leaders. If a Muslim community builds a mosque that does similar things, the existence of those programs doesn't prove that somebody is carrying out a 1991 Muslim Brotherhood strategy. Likewise, a Muslim student becoming a lawyer, journalist, professor, politician, or community leader doesn't prove an infiltration program.
That's where evidence matters. If we are going to claim an organization is carrying out this strategy, then show me the connection. Show me the leadership. Show me the internal communications. Show me the money. Show me the organizational records. Show me the directives. Don't just show me somebody who happens to be Muslim. That's not evidence.
Then We Get to the Holy Land Foundation
This is where I think the argument changes. Because now we're not talking about theories. We're talking about convictions in federal court. In 2008, the Holy Land Foundation and five of its leaders were convicted on charges involving material support for Hamas. The Justice Department announced the verdicts. The FBI reported that about $12.4 million had gone to Hamas-controlled organizations. The defendants appealed, and the individual convictions and sentences were upheld by the Fifth Circuit. Now let's be precise about this too. The appellate court described this as a case about financial support. The defendants weren't convicted of personally carrying out specific terrorist attacks.
But the underlying point remains. This was a real organization operating in the United States, publicly presenting itself as a charitable organization, whose leaders were convicted of providing material support to Hamas. That's not Islamophobia. That's a court record. And it proves something important: The possibility that a legitimate-looking organization could have another purpose underneath the surface was not imaginary. It happened. At least in that case. And those last five words matter.
Because One Conviction Doesn't Convict Everybody Else
This is where I part company with people who take the Holy Land Foundation case and run far beyond what it proves. A Muslim organization listed in a historical document isn't automatically guilty of terrorism. An organization once described by government lawyers as an unindicted co-conspirator wasn't convicted simply because the government put its name on a list. A Muslim working in government isn't evidence of infiltration. A Muslim immigrant isn't evidence of a Muslim Brotherhood demographic strategy. And a Muslim American who has never heard of Mohamed Akram shouldn't be treated as though that person somehow signed onto a document written in 1991.
If we do that, we've stopped investigating. We have started stereotyping.
Immigration Doesn't Prove It Either
This came up during my research because Europe has experienced significant Muslim population growth. That is real. Migration contributed to it. So did demographics, including age structure and fertility. Those are legitimate things for a country to discuss. Immigration policy isn't immune from debate simply because religion might be part of the conversation. But here is the problem. What evidence proves that the Muslim Brotherhood orchestrated that immigration? I haven't found it. Maybe somebody someday produces documents that establish something more. If that happens, examine them.
Until then, population growth is population growth. It isn't proof of the Brotherhood's 1991 plan.
Terrorism Can't Become a Shortcut Either
The same rule applies to terrorism. Jihadist terrorism exists. Pretending otherwise would be foolish. Europol tracks it. CSIS tracks jihadist attacks and plots in the United States. Governments around the world spend enormous resources combating it. That is a security issue. But “jihadist” and “Muslim” don't mean the same thing. If we begin using the behavior of jihadist terrorists to describe Muslims generally, then we've made exactly the analytical mistake we claim we're trying to expose. And I refuse to do that.
But Don't Use “Islamophobia” to Shut Down the Question
Here's the other side of this. I'm also not willing to accept the idea that examining political Islam, Islamism, the Muslim Brotherhood, terrorism financing, foreign funding, or extremist organizations is somehow automatically anti-Muslim. It's not. We investigate political movements all the time. We investigate Christian nationalist organizations. We investigate white supremacists. We investigate communist organizations. We investigate violent left-wing and right-wing extremist groups. We investigate corporations, unions, political parties, charities, churches, government agencies, and elected officials. Why should the Muslim Brotherhood get an exemption? It shouldn't.
And the same thing can happen with the phrase “white supremacy.”
Let me be clear: white supremacy is real. Anti-Muslim bigotry is real. There are genuine extremists who target Muslims because of who they are or what they believe. When the evidence shows that, call it what it is.
But, Anti-White bigotry exists also.
But “white supremacy” cannot become another label thrown at every person who asks hard questions about political Islam, Islamist organizations, foreign funding, terrorism financing, or the Muslim Brotherhood. If the response to a documented question is simply to brand the person asking it a racist or white supremacist, then the label has replaced the argument.
Show me the racism. Show me the supremacist ideology. Show me the evidence. If it is there, condemn it. If it is not, answer the question.
That standard has to work both ways. We should not use the Muslim Brotherhood to smear Muslims, and we should not use accusations of white supremacy to make documented questions off-limits.
Muslim Americans deserve protection against discrimination. The Muslim Brotherhood deserves scrutiny based on the evidence. Both statements can be true.
So What Do I Think?
After going through this material, I keep coming back to the question we started with:
Valid concern or Islamophobia?
My answer is this:
There is valid concern here.
The document is real. The language is real. The historical organization is real. Connections between Brotherhood figures and American institutions are worthy of investigation. And the Holy Land Foundation case proves that concern about concealed organizational activity was justified in at least one major instance. I'm not willing to dismiss all of that by throwing the word “Islamophobia” at anyone who asks questions. But I'm equally unwilling to pretend we've proven things we haven't. We haven't proven that every organization historically connected to Brotherhood figures remains under Brotherhood control today.
We haven't proven that Muslim immigration is a Brotherhood operation. We haven't proven that every Muslim political activist is part of some hidden strategy. And we certainly haven't proven that Muslims as a religious community should be treated with suspicion. That's not what the evidence says.
The Standard Is Actually Pretty Simple
Follow the documents. Follow the organizations. Follow the leadership. Follow the money. Follow the court records. Follow the conduct. And when the evidence stops, we stop. That's what Embers of Truth is supposed to be about. Not protecting a narrative. Not defending a political side. Not being afraid of an uncomfortable question. Finding the ember underneath all the smoke and asking whether it can survive the light of the evidence. The Muslim Brotherhood memorandum deserves that examination. So do the organizations connected to it. But Muslim Americans also deserve something from us.
They deserve to be judged as individuals, by their actions and by the evidence, just like everybody else. We shouldn't be frightened away from legitimate questions by accusations of Islamophobia. But we shouldn't become what we're accused of being either.
Investigate the movement.
Follow the evidence.
Don't indict a faith.
Source Notes
• 1991 Explanatory Memorandum / Government Exhibit 003-0085: https://translations.meforum.org/documents/muslim-brotherhood-explanatory-memorandum-1991/
• U.S. Department of Justice, Holy Land Foundation conviction: https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/txn/PressRel08/HLF_convict_pr.html
• U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, United States v. El-Mezain et al.: https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/09/09-10560-CR0.wpd.pdf
• George Washington University Program on Extremism, The Muslim Brotherhood in America: https://extremism.gwu.edu/muslim-brotherhood-america-brief-history
• Pew Research Center, Europe’s Growing Muslim Population: https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/11/29/europes-growing-muslim-population/
• Europol, EU Terrorism Situation and Trend Report 2025: https://www.europol.europa.eu/publication-events/main-reports/european-union-terrorism-situation-and-trend-report-2025-eu-te-sat
• CSIS, U.S. Terrorism Incidents Dataset: https://www.csis.org/programs/warfare-irregular-threats-and-terrorism-program/us-terrorism-incidents-dataset
• Context on Islamophobia and white supremacy: Cambridge University Press / Manchester University Press, “Islamophobia and the struggle against white supremacy,” https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/global-white-nationalism/postscript-islamophobia-and-the-struggle-against-white-supremacy/DECE67AE0C0471A35C4704026BC51F92
• Context on Islamophobia, race, and criticism of Islam: Yaqeen Institute, “What is Islamophobia? Race, Power, and the Roots of Anti-Muslim Discrimination,” https://yaqeeninstitute.org/read/paper/what-is-islamophobia-race-power-and-the-roots-of-anti-muslim-discrimination





Comments